Heinnie's Back Barn Menu (2025 Update)
Heinnie's Back Barn is a hidden gem in Elkhart, IN, offering a unique dining experience in the unclaimed category of steakhouses and sandwiches. With a range of utilities like reservations, takeout, delivery, and catering options, this restaurant caters to a diverse range of customers. The menu boasts many vegetarian options, making it a great choice for all diners. The casual atmosphere with moderate noise levels, outdoor seating, and a full bar creates a welcoming and relaxed environment. The friendly staff provides excellent waiter service, ensuring a memorable dining experience. With amenities like TV, Wi-Fi, and dogs allowed, Heinnie's Back Barn goes above and beyond to accommodate their customers. Don't miss out on trying their dishes- it's a must-visit destination for a satisfying dinner.
APPETIZERS
POTATO WEDGES
Melted Mexican cheese, bacon and sour cream
ZUCCHINI STICKS
Lightly battered zucchini sticks served with horseradish mustard
PRETZEL BITES
Served with nacho cheese sauce
ONION RINGS
Thick cut beer battered onion rings
MOZZARELLA STICKS
Breaded mozzarella sticks served with house marinara sauce
TACO STICKS
Crispy wrapped tortilla filled with taco meat, served with nacho cheese
JALAPENO POPPERS
Cheddar cheese stuffed jalapenos served with ranch dipping sauce
COMBO PLATTER
Beer Battered Onion Rings, Zucchini Sticks, Jalapeno Poppers and Mozzarella Sticks
SWEET POTATO FRIES
Served with a side of cinnamon butter
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
cooked shrimp with shrimp horseradish sauce
CHEESE & CRACKERS
Cheddar horseradish cheese with assorted crackers
MOJO'S
Sliced potatoes breaded and deep fried
CHICKEN BREAST SALAD
Charbroiled chicken breast with Romaine blend, cabbage, carrots, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, cheese and crouton
STEAK SALAD
oz charbroiled sirloin with Romaine blend, cabbage, carrots, Grilled onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, cheese and crouton
CHICKEN BANG SALAD
A breaded chicken breast with bang sauce drizzled on it, romaine blend, cabbage, carrots, onion, tomatoes, cucumber, cheese and croutons
CHEF SALAD
Romaine blend, chopped tomatoes, onions, ham, turkey, cheese and egg
HOUSE SALAD
Romaine blend, cabbage, carrots, tomatoes, onions and cucumbers
HOMEMADE CHILLI
Bowl of Soup
HAM & NAVY BEAN
Bowl of Soup
BEEF VEGETABLE
Bowl of Soup
SOUP OF THE DAY
Bowl of Soup (Thursday-Sat)
SOUPS & SALADS
BURGERS
OZ ANGUS STEAK SANDWICH
day wet aged Angus steak and grilled onions on a hoagie bun. Served with Fries.
CHEESEBURGER
/ burger topped with American cheese. Served with Fries.
HEINNIE CHEESEBURGER
Burger with onions and seasonings topped with American cheese. Served with Fries.
CLAYBAUGH
Double / cheeseburger topped with mozzarella, American, Swiss, cheddar cheese, bacon, mushrooms, lettuce, tomato, onion, ketchup, mustard, pickle, and mayo. Served with Fries.
HEINNIES MELT
/ lb Heinnies burger on grilled Texas toast with bacon, cheese, and thousand island dressing. Served with Fries.
PATTY MELT
Heinnieburger with grilled onions & Swiss on grilled rye bread. Served with Fries.
CHILIBURGER
Heinnieburger open face with chili, onion and cheddar cheese. Served with Fries.
CREATE YOUR OWN BURGER
/ lb. Served with Fries.
HEINNIE PORK TENDERLOIN
Cut from pork tenderloin, grilled or deep fried. Served with Fries.
BIG HAM & CHEESE
/ pound shaved ham, topped with American and mozzarella cheese on a hoagie bun. Served with Fries.
ITALIAN SAUSAGE
oz Italian sausage smothered in grilled onions with mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce on a hoagie bun. Served with Fries.
BLT
strips of bacon on Texas white toast, topped with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Served with Fries.
CHICKEN BREAST SANDWICH
oz. breast of grilled or breaded chicken, add whatever toppings you'd like. Served with Fries.
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH
oz chicken breast topped with wing sauce and Swiss cheese. Served with Fries.
PHILLY CHEESESTEAK SANDWICH
With side of au jus. Served with Fries.
SANDWICHES
SEAFOOD & CHICKEN
SALMON
Charbroiled or baked oz Norwegian salmon
SHRIMP DINNER
Breaded or charbroiled
HADDOCK DINNER
Hand breaded and deep fried or baked as a fish filet
MAHI MAHI
Charbroiled
CHICKEN DINNER
piece hand breaded and deep fried
SMOTHERED CHICKEN DINNER
Charbroiled chicken breast with mushrooms, grilled onions and mozzarella cheese. Single Breast
CHICKEN STRIPS & FRIES
KRAFT MAC AND CHEESE
All meals include Tater Tots, Apple Sauce and a Drink
CHICKEN STRIPS
All meals include Tater Tots, Apple Sauce and a Drink
MINI CORN DOGS
All meals include Tater Tots, Apple Sauce and a Drink
PEANUT BUTTER & JELLY
All meals include Tater Tots, Apple Sauce and a Drink
GRILLED CHEESE
All meals include Tater Tots, Apple Sauce and a Drink